BiPathCPG A Novel Load-Sharing Design Architecture for Compound Planetary Gearboxes

Deepak Kapa*,1,2 Aman Singh*,1 Saketh Vegesna1 Suryank Joshi1 Mayank Goswami2 Shishir Kolathaya1

1Dept. of Cyber-Physical Systems, Indian Institute of Science, Bengaluru, India

2Dept. of Physics, Indian Institute of Technology Roorkee, India

*Equal contribution

Photo of the black 3D-printed CPG actuator (85.3 mm tall) next to the blue BiPathCPG actuator (78.9 mm tall), with a bar chart comparing backlash, stiffness, efficiency, mass and width.
3D-printed actuators: conventional Compound Planetary Gearbox (CPG, left, 820 g) and BiPathCPG (right, 795 g).

Abstract

Quasi-Direct Drive (QDD) actuators are widely used in legged robots due to their low reflected inertia, high backdrivability, and high torque density, commonly employing planetary or cycloidal gearboxes. Single-stage planetary gearboxes offer high efficiency but limited torque density; multi-stage designs improve torque density at the cost of efficiency; and cycloidal gearboxes provide high stiffness but suffer from torque ripple. Compound Planetary Gearboxes (CPG) offer a compromise, but conventional designs result in increased actuator width, mass, and reduced torsional stiffness in 3D-printed actuators. This paper proposes the BiPath Compound Planetary Gearbox (BiPathCPG), a novel architecture that introduces an idle second-stage sun gear and load-sharing second-stage planets within the otherwise unused space of a conventional CPG to simultaneously improve stiffness, reduce actuator width, and reduce mass. An optimization framework computes BiPathCPG parameters for a given motor and target gear ratio. The architecture is validated through a 3D-printed proof-of-concept actuator design, benchmarked against a conventional CPG using custom-built test rigs. The BiPathCPG achieves a torsional stiffness of 1394 N·m/rad, a 1.70× improvement over the conventional CPG, with a 32% reduction in backlash, 25 g lower mass, and approximately 6.4 mm reduction in axial width, while achieving a peak stall torque of 36.49 N·m.

Interactive 3D Model

Loading 3D model…
Drag to rotate · Scroll to zoom · Right-drag to pan

BiPathCPG actuator (i ≈ 14:1, MAD M6C12 motor). Hover over a part to see its name.

Architecture

Front views, line diagrams and isometric views of the conventional CPG (top row) and the BiPathCPG (bottom row).
Gearbox architectures: (a)–(c) CPG and (d)–(f) BiPathCPG, shown as front view, line diagram and isometric view, respectively. S: sun, P1/P2: first-/second-stage planets, R: ring, C: carrier. iS2 and iP2 denote the idle second-stage sun and planet gears of the BiPathCPG.

Actuator Design

Exploded CAD view of the BiPathCPG actuator with labelled parts, and a sectional view.
BiPathCPG: (a) exploded view, (b) sectional view.

Results

Eight-panel bench comparison of the CPG and BiPathCPG: efficiency, backlash, backdrive torque, stiffness and peak torque.
Bench comparison of the CPG and BiPathCPG at i ≈ 14:1. (a), (b) Mechanical efficiency versus commanded torque at 20–120 rpm; the shaded band marks the saturated region above 12 N·m and the dash-dot line its mean. (c), (d) Output deflection under a ±2 N·m fixed-output load cycle. (e), (f) Static load-cell torque during the backdriving ramp, with circles marking motion onset. (g) Output deflection versus torque with forward and backward linear fits. (h) Load-cell torque for a 40 N·m command.